The important thing is the color I saw in the video and that the pencils are soft and spread well on the skin.

Also, make sure they’re not too creamy, because they tend to break a lot. The tip always gets destroyed, so it needs to be medium-hard.

The important thing is the color I saw in the video and that the pencils are soft and spread well on the skin. Also, make sure they’re not too creamy, because they tend to break a lot. The tip always gets destroyed, so it needs to be medium-hard.

When it comes to makeup, especially products like eye or lip pencils, finding the perfect formula is a real journey. It’s not just about color—although that’s often what catches your eye first—but also about the texture, application, durability, and how the product behaves over time. This brings us to a very specific and often overlooked truth in the world of makeup: The important thing is the color I saw in the video and that the pencils are soft and spread well on the skin. Also, make sure they’re not too creamy, because they tend to break a lot. The tip always gets destroyed, so it needs to be medium-hard.

Let’s unpack this sentence, because inside it lies the ultimate checklist for anyone looking to invest in a quality makeup pencil.

The Color I Saw in the Video

In today’s world, beauty products are often discovered online before we ever see them in person. Whether it’s a YouTube tutorial, an Instagram reel, or a TikTok review, the first thing that draws us in is the color. But there’s a problem: what you see on screen doesn’t always match what shows up in real life. That’s why it’s so important that the product actually looks like what you saw in the video. If the color payoff is disappointing or the undertone is off, it can completely change how the makeup looks on your skin.

A great pencil should deliver on that promise—it should show up bold and accurate on the first swipe, matching what you saw on the screen. That means strong pigmentation, rich saturation, and a formula that doesn’t fade or get chalky. Whether you’re going for a sultry black eyeliner, a perfect nude lip, or a fun pop of teal, the shade has to be spot-on.

Soft and Spreads Well on the Skin

Now, let’s talk about texture. A pencil should glide easily without tugging or scratching. This is especially important when you’re working around sensitive areas like the eyes or lips. A soft pencil ensures that you can draw clean lines, smudge if needed, or fill in larger areas without discomfort.

Pencils that spread well are more versatile. You can use them for precise lining or blend them out for a smokier effect. Think of a lip liner that also works as a lipstick base, or an eyeliner that doubles as a cream shadow. The key is a texture that is smooth enough to apply easily but not so soft that it melts or smears uncontrollably.

Not Too Creamy—Because They Tend to Break

Here’s the tricky part. While we want our pencils to be soft, we don’t want them too creamy. Why? Because overly creamy pencils often come with a downside: fragility. These types of formulas may feel luxurious at first, but they tend to break easily—either in the sharpener or during application. There’s nothing more frustrating than buying a beautiful pencil, only for the tip to snap off again and again.

Creamy pencils also melt more quickly in warmer weather, making them less durable and harder to control. If you’re someone who carries makeup in your bag or lives in a hot climate, this becomes a real issue. The ideal pencil strikes a balance—it should feel soft and blendable, but not so creamy that it can’t hold its form.

The Tip Always Gets Destroyed

This point ties closely to creaminess. If a pencil is too soft, the tip becomes fragile. Every time you sharpen it, it feels like you’re losing half the product. And when the tip gets squashed or destroyed in your makeup bag, it’s not just a mess—it’s a waste of money.

You need a pencil that keeps its shape, one you can sharpen to a fine point and use with precision. Whether you’re creating a winged liner, outlining your lips, or drawing brow hairs, a good tip is essential. It’s not just about neatness—it’s about control.

It Needs to Be Medium-Hard

So what’s the solution? Medium-hard pencils. They’re the goldilocks of the makeup world—not too soft, not too hard. They offer just enough give to apply smoothly, while being firm enough to hold a fine tip and resist breaking. This kind of formula gives you the best of both worlds: performance and durability.

Medium-hard pencils also tend to be longer-lasting. They don’t smudge as easily, and once they set, they stay put. Whether you’re wearing them all day or through a night out, they won’t disappear halfway through.

Final Thoughts

Choosing the right makeup pencil might seem simple, but there’s a lot more to it than meets the eye. It’s not just about the packaging or the brand name—it’s about how the product performs. From the true-to-video color to the feel of the formula on your skin, every detail matters. A great pencil should:

• Look exactly like the shade you fell in love with online
• Glide on smoothly without dragging
• Blend easily when needed
• Be firm enough to avoid breaking
• Hold a sharp point for precision
• Stay put throughout the day

This is why so many makeup lovers search tirelessly for that perfect pencil. We want something that doesn’t just look good, but works—something that’s reliable, easy to use, and worth every penny. Whether you’re a makeup artist or a casual beauty fan, you know the frustration of pencils that are too soft, too hard, or simply not the color you expected.

So next time you’re shopping for a new eyeliner, brow pencil, or lip liner, keep this in mind: The important thing is the color you saw in the video and that the pencils are soft and spread well on the skin. Also, make sure they’re not too creamy, because they tend to break a lot. The tip always gets destroyed, so it needs to be medium-hard.

That one sentence might just be the ultimate buying guide. And once you find that perfect pencil, you’ll never settle for less.